What We Owe the Future
The book in brief. William MacAskill sorts the ways of affecting the far future into two families. A speed-up moves the same civilisation along the same road at a different rate. A trajectory change alters the average value of civilisation over the whole of its remaining life. Survival and trajectory dwarf acceleration, provided acceleration does not change the long-term state we end up in.
Key ideas
- Significance, persistence, contingency. A change is worth how much better it makes the world, how long it lasts, and how long the world would have waited for it had nobody acted.
- Acceleration is capped. A technology whose only effect is to arrive four years early is worth four years of its own benefits.
- Plasticity, then rigidity. Some moments carry outsized long-run effects because many outcomes are still available before the system hardens, like molten glass cooling.
- Value lock-in. A single value system written into a durable enough system can persist for an extremely long time, and the arrival of artificial general intelligence could fix whichever values prevail at that moment.
Why it matters to my work. In MacAskill on Speed-Ups and Trajectory Changes, I apply the framework to venture capital: most competitive deals are speed-ups, able to score on significance and persistence but low on contingency, since several funds would have backed them. I also argue that the distinction holds over a narrower range than his figure suggests, because for a technology that fixes defaults on arrival, how fast it arrives is part of what gets settled.
