★★★★★ · 2012 #economics#startup

Doing Capitalism in the Innovation Economy

by William H. Janeway

The book in brief. I draw on William Janeway for two points: the public origins of the technologies that venture capital takes to market, and the place of Knightian uncertainty in the funding of innovation.

Key ideas

  • Public money upstream. The transistor, the packet-switched network, satellite positioning and the statistics behind machine learning came out of public and military research budgets, a point Janeway pressed for four decades from inside a venture seat.
  • Risk is not uncertainty. The book draws the distinction Frank Knight made in 1921 between measurable risk and unmeasurable uncertainty.

Why it matters to my work. In MacAskill on Speed-Ups and Trajectory Changes, the first point supports my argument that venture added the push to a mass market, which is a different claim from having caused the technology to exist. In The Prediction Market and the Wisdom of the Few, I use the second: reading a thin market on a unique event as a calibrated probability treats Knightian uncertainty as if it were risk.