★★★★★ · 1995 #philosophy#classification#psychiatry

Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Sciences of Memory

by Ian Hacking

The book in brief. Ian Hacking argues that human kinds, unlike natural kinds, produce looping effects. Once a category of person is published it reaches the people it labels, they change because of it, and the category is then revised to fit them.

Key ideas

  • Looping effects. People recognise themselves in a category, organise around it, contest or embrace it, and so alter what the category describes.
  • No one controls the loop. The revisions run beyond the reach of those who first named the kind.
  • Multiple personality as the signature case. The diagnosis went from a handful of recorded cases in the 1970s to tens of thousands by the late 1990s, then receded as the diagnostic frame shifted.

Why it matters to my work. In Carving at the Joints: On Segmentation, Its Limits, Its Use Hacking marks the point where classification changes because the classified can read about it. I extend his reading to the DSM-5 threshold for major depressive disorder and to autism as the live case today, and I pair it with its inverse: if categories make their objects, a deliberately substituted category can sometimes unmake the problem. In the sequel on classification at machine speed I argue that the loop he described, which once took decades, now closes in seconds through foundation models.