· 1923 #philosophy

I and Thou

by Martin Buber

The book in brief. In Ich und Du (1923), Martin Buber distinguishes two fundamental modes of encounter. The I-It is the relation to anything treated as an object, a means or a tool. The I-Thou is the relation to another as a whole subject, fully present and not reducible to any function they perform.

Key ideas

  • I-It. The relation to whatever we use, however useful it may be.
  • I-Thou. The relation to another met as a whole subject, in the fullness of their presence.
  • Becoming human. Buber claims that we become fully human only in I-Thou encounters.
  • The cost of efficiency. A life spent entirely in I-It relations can be efficient and still starve something constitutive.

Why it matters to my work. In AI, Intimacy, and the Unreciprocating Companion, Buber came to mind as I listened to what the guests at a dinner on AI and intimacy were reaching for. I use his distinction to place the AI companion: it is the most refined It we have ever built, and a Thou requires someone to be there on the other side.